How Do You Get Car Insurance With a Bad Driving Record?
Jeffrey CarvalhoCA License #0783367
· 14 min read

Last Updated: October 25, 2026
Quick Summary
To get car insurance with a bad driving record, handle the most serious mark first, then compare quotes from at least three carriers, including one that writes nonstandard auto. Insurers rate each violation differently, so the same driver can get wildly different quotes from three companies. Confirm any SR-22 or FR-44 filing requirement with your state DMV before you shop.
- A DUI can triple your premium or push you out of the standard market entirely.
- Insurance.com's 2026 data puts coverage for a bad driving record between $210 and $669 per month depending on the state.
- The Zebra names Travelers at $1,159 as the cheapest option for bad drivers in its analysis.
- Keep continuous coverage from the day of a DUI conviction forward, since a lapse can restart your suspension.
- Re-shop every six months after a DUI because surcharges drop sharply as the conviction ages.
Table of Contents
- What Counts as a Bad Driving Record for Insurance
- High-Risk Car Insurance: What It Is and Who Offers It
- Step-by-Step: How to Get Covered With a Bad Driving Record
- Car Insurance After a DUI: What Changes and What to Do
- How Long Accidents Stay on Your Driving Record
- Compare Car Insurance Quotes With a Bad Driving Record
- Request a Free Quote and Review Your Options
- Frequently Asked Questions
What Counts as a Bad Driving Record for Insurance
A bad driving record is a history of tickets, accidents, or license problems that makes an insurer see you as a higher risk to cover. That record decides whether you get standard coverage or end up shopping for high-risk car insurance.
Insurers pull your motor vehicle record and rate every mark on it. Here is what they look at:
- Traffic violations: speeding tickets, reckless driving, and failure to stop
- At-fault accidents: crashes where you were found responsible
- DUI convictions: the single most damaging entry on most records
Violations, Accidents, and How Insurers Rate the Risk
Not every mark carries the same weight. A single speeding ticket might add a small amount to your premium. A DUI can triple it or push you out of the standard market entirely.
According to Insurify's 2026 analysis of bad driving records, car insurance for people with an incident on their record averages $120 per month, though the figure depends heavily on the violation and coverage level.
Each insurer weighs these marks differently. That is why the same driver can get wildly different quotes from three companies.
High-Risk Car Insurance: What It Is and Who Offers It
High-risk car insurance is coverage sold to drivers that standard insurers avoid, usually after accidents, DUIs, or repeated violations.
At Farmers Insurance, we work like a broker, which means we can shop your record across multiple carriers rather than pushing one company's rate.
Insurance.com's 2026 rate data puts coverage for a bad driving record between $210 and $669 per month depending on the state.
A few carriers stand out for high-risk drivers.
Step-by-Step: How to Get Covered With a Bad Driving Record
Getting covered with a bad record is not one process, it is four different processes depending on what is on your record. A single speeding ticket, an at-fault accident, a DUI conviction, and a license suspension each trigger different insurer rules, different state filing requirements, and different timelines. Work the plan that matches your situation, then use the shared final steps to compare and buy.

If Your Mark Is a Speeding Ticket or Minor Moving Violation
- Pull your motor vehicle record from your state DMV. Confirm the ticket date, the court disposition, and the points assessed. A ticket that was dismissed or reduced in traffic court should not still be scoring against you.
- Check whether your state offers a defensive driving dismissal. Many states allow you to take an approved course to remove points or keep the ticket off your record entirely, but only if you act within the court's window, often 30 to 90 days.
- Ask each insurer how it treats a single minor violation. Some carriers overlook one ticket entirely; others surcharge it for three years. The spread between those two behaviors is often $40 to $80 per month for the same driver.
- Compare at least three quotes and ask specifically about a good-driver or telematics discount. A single ticket usually keeps you in the standard market, so you have more leverage than you think.
If Your Mark Is an At-Fault Accident
- Confirm fault on your record. Insurers rate on the at-fault determination, not the crash itself. If the other driver was cited, make sure your record reflects that.
- Check whether your state uses a surcharge schedule. Many states publish a point schedule that caps how much an insurer can surcharge for a single accident; knowing the cap tells you when a quote is out of line.
- Decide whether to file the claim through your own collision coverage or pay out of pocket. A small at-fault claim can cost more in premium over three years than the repair itself.
- Shop at least three carriers, including one that specializes in nonstandard auto. Accident surcharges vary more between insurers than any other mark.
If Your Mark Is a DUI Conviction
- Confirm your SR-22 or FR-44 filing requirement with your state DMV before you shop. The filing obligation, the required coverage limits, and the filing duration differ by state, and an insurer that cannot file in your state is useless to you no matter the price.
- Get quotes only from carriers that file SR-22s directly. Ask the agent to confirm in writing that the filing will be submitted on your behalf.
- Keep continuous coverage from the day of conviction forward. A single lapse during the filing period can restart your suspension.
- Re-shop every six months. DUI surcharges drop sharply as the conviction ages, and the carrier that was cheapest in year one is rarely cheapest in year three.
If Your Mark Is a License Suspension
- Reinstate the license first. Most insurers will not quote a driver with an active suspension, and any quote you get will not hold.
- Ask your state DMV whether an SR-22 is required to reinstate. In many states it is, and the filing must be in place before the license is restored.
- Expect to start in the nonstandard market. Suspensions usually push drivers out of preferred carriers for at least three years.
- Document the reinstatement date. That date, not the original suspension date, usually starts the clock on how long insurers surcharge you.
The Shared Final Steps
Once you have handled the violation-specific items above, finish with the same three moves every high-risk driver should make:
- Gather your documents: license, proof of prior coverage, SR-22 paperwork if applicable, and your motor vehicle record.
- Compare at least three quotes with identical coverage limits. A cheap quote with state-minimum limits is not comparable to a full-coverage quote.
- Ask about every discount you qualify for: multi-policy, paid-in-full, telematics, and approved defensive driving. Stacked, these can offset a meaningful share of a violation surcharge.
Car Insurance After a DUI: What Changes and What to Do
Car insurance after a DUI costs more and often requires an SR-22 filing, which is a form your insurer sends to the state proving you carry coverage. Expect to move into the high-risk market for a few years.
Here is what to do after a DUI:
- File the SR-22 the same day it is required. A lapse can trigger another suspension.
- Keep continuous coverage. Never let a policy lapse, even for a day.
- Ask about approved defensive driving courses. A-MAX Insurance reports potential savings of 5% to 10% in most states, though State Farm advises checking with an agent that your course is approved.
How Long Accidents Stay on Your Driving Record
Accidents and violations stay on your driving record for a set period, and insurers usually care about the last three to five years. The exact window depends on your state and the type of mark.
Here is the general picture:
| Mark on Your Record | Typical Impact Window | What to Do |
|---|---|---|
| Speeding ticket | 3 years | Take a defensive driving course |
| At-fault accident | 3 to 5 years | Keep continuous coverage |
| DUI conviction | 5 to 10 years | Maintain SR-22 filing |
| License suspension | Until reinstated | Reinstate before shopping |
The clock matters. A violation from four years ago carries far less weight than one from last month, so the best time to shop is often right after a mark ages off.
Compare Car Insurance Quotes With a Bad Driving Record
Comparing quotes is the highest-leverage move you can make with a bad record, because the spread between the cheapest and most expensive carrier for the same driver is often hundreds of dollars a year, wider than for any other driver segment. But comparison only works if you compare like for like, and it only helps if you know what to do when every quote comes back higher than you can pay or when a carrier declines you outright.
Compare Like for Like
Use this checklist every time you pull a quote:
- Get quotes from at least three carriers, including one that writes nonstandard auto
- Match bodily injury and property damage limits exactly across every quote
- Confirm whether uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage is included
A low advertised rate means little if the limits differ. Compare like for like, or you are comparing nothing.
When the Quotes Are Unaffordable
If every quote exceeds your budget, work through these trade-offs in order before you consider dropping coverage:
- Raise your deductibles. Moving from a $500 to a $1,000 deductible on collision and comprehensive typically lowers the premium meaningfully, and it is reversible once your record improves.
- Drop optional coverages, not required ones. If your state only requires liability, you can legally carry liability only, but understand that you are then personally exposed for your own vehicle and for any damage above your limits.
- Reduce coverage on an older vehicle. Full coverage on a car worth less than a few thousand dollars rarely pays for itself.
- Ask about a named-driver exclusion or a low-mileage plan if another household member rarely drives.
- Never drop coverage entirely to save money. A lapse is itself a rating factor, it can trigger an SR-22 violation and a new suspension, and it usually costs more in future premium than it saves today.
Request a Free Quote and Review Your Options
The hardest part of a bad record is not finding coverage. It is knowing whether the quote in front of you is actually fair.
At Farmers Insurance, we have spent 38 years helping drivers in exactly this spot. We shop your record across multiple carriers, so you see real options side by side instead of one company's guess.
Get started with Farmers Insurance and see what your record actually qualifies for.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I get car insurance after multiple tickets or accidents?
Start by requesting your motor vehicle record so you know exactly what insurers will see, then fix any errors before you shop. Compare quotes from several carriers, because companies assess a bad driving record differently and the price spread is widest for drivers with imperfect records. Ask about defensive-driving discounts, which A-MAX reports can save 5% to 10% in most states, and keep continuous coverage so you don't add a lapse to your record.
How long do accidents and tickets affect car insurance rates?
Most insurers look back several years, but the exact violation period varies by carrier and state. The impact of infractions varies by company. Because the effect fades over time, it pays to re-shop your policy periodically rather than assuming your current rate is the best you can get with a bad driving record.
Do I need an SR-22 after a serious driving violation?
An SR-22 filing is typically required after serious violations such as a DUI conviction or license suspension, and the requirement depends on your state. A-MAX advises filing the SR-22 the same day it is required and avoiding coverage lapses while it is active. Ask your insurer whether they handle SR-22 filings directly, since not every carrier does, and confirm the exact filing period with your state's licensing agency.
What should I do if insurance companies deny me coverage?
A denial is not the end of the road. Ask the insurer why you were declined, then request your motor vehicle record to check for errors that may be inflating your risk profile. Work with an agency that can access multiple carriers, since high-risk auto insurance is offered by a narrower set of companies. If you are nonrenewed, line up new coverage before your current policy ends to avoid an insurance lapse.
A bad driving record raises your rate, but it does not close the door on coverage. The drivers who save the most are the ones who check their record for errors, compare several carriers, and keep their coverage continuous. That is where we come in. Request a free quote from Farmers Insurance today and let us review your options with you.